Sisters get 5 years probation in Livermore child abuse case

Bound babies with blankets during naptime at child care facility

Two sisters were sentenced today to five years' probation for their felony conviction for willfully harming a child for binding babies with blankets during naptime at a Livermore child care facility.

Nazila Sharaf, 36, of Dublin, and Lida Sharaf, 34, of Mountain House, pleaded no contest to the charge on Nov. 10 and were sentenced by Alameda County Superior Court Judge Dan Grimmer today.

Both women initially were charged with three counts of felony child neglect and abuse and four counts of misdemeanor child neglect and abuse.

The Sharaf sisters have been free on bail but Nazila was sentenced to 60 days in jail, a term that she can serve via electronic ankle monitoring, prosecutor Mark Melton said.

The sisters won't be allowed to run a day care center or be employed as a licensed worker at such a facility, Melton said.

Livermore police began investigating the case in March 2013 after they were asked to help the California Department of Social Services shut down the Universal Preschool LCC at 1040 Florence Road in Livermore. The investigation wrapped up a month later, on April 15, 2013.

Livermore police spokesman Steve Goard said the investigation revealed that the Sharaf sisters had allegedly bound at least seven of the babies' upper torsos and legs with blankets and other cloth-type materials during naps.

Those actions allegedly restricted the babies' ability to breathe comfortably and move their extremities, Goard said.

Police said the sisters also threw blankets over the bound babies' faces.

The babies ranged in age from 7 months to 11 months, and three had respiratory conditions, according to police.

Authorities were alerted about the alleged activity by a 19-year-old former employee who quit the facility in late 2011, according to Goard.

The former employee, whose name was sealed in court documents to protect her privacy, filed complaints with the state, which conducted its own investigation. According to Goard, the swaddling of an infant over 6 months old should be done only at the request of a parent.

According to a report by the Alameda County District Attorney's Office, being restrained caused the babies to suffer both mentally and physically.

However, Melton said there isn't any proof that any of the children who were at the day care facility were injured.

There will be a hearing in March to determine whether the Sharaf sisters should pay restitution to the victims in the case, Melton said.

In addition, the family of one victim has filed a civil lawsuit to seek damages from the sisters, according to Melton.

— Bay City News Service


Like this comment
Posted by Sabryna
a resident of Another Pleasanton neighborhood
on Jan 8, 2015 at 8:40 am

They got off too easy! they should have to serve their time in jail and pay restitution to the families, a weekly or monthly amount so every time they write the check they will be reminded of their cruelty for the rest of their lives. Then bind them tightly for a period of time each day. A slap on the wrist is no kind of punishment!!

Like this comment
Posted by Julia
a resident of another community
on Jan 8, 2015 at 10:03 am

We take a baby's emotions for granted. They have fears as we do.

The Judge, Mr. Dan Grimmer should allow someone to wrap an roll him up in a rug and see how he handles the stress of confinement.

I don't think the Judge would like it much...but they are only babies what do they know....well fool think again.

I fine his actions irresponsible and cruel for babies.

Just my opinion...thank you for listening, Julia Pardini from Alamo

1 person likes this
Posted by Ed
a resident of Pleasanton Meadows
on Jan 8, 2015 at 3:12 pm

Why not let the parents of those kids have 5 minutes alone with those sisters in a locked room? Then we'd see justice. But we live in a "civilized world" so that can't happen.
Too bad

1 person likes this
Posted by Formerly Dan from BC
a resident of Bridle Creek
on Jan 8, 2015 at 4:17 pm

Formerly Dan from BC is a registered user.

What a travesty of justice...

The judge should hang his head in shame.

Like this comment
Posted by sadden parent
a resident of Livermore
on Jan 9, 2015 at 8:27 am

the parents must be devastated.

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Couples: “Everything is a gift of the universe . . .
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 747 views

Fighting to wipe out changing our clocks
By Tim Hunt | 12 comments | 582 views

How Well Is Your High School Preparing Your Student for College
By Elizabeth LaScala | 0 comments | 315 views