Foothill High student shot, killed in baseball attack on police officer

Police respond to domestic violence dispute on Dublin Meadows Street

Oscar Herrera, 18, a student at Foothill High School in Pleasanton, was shot and killed by a Dublin police officer late Sunday as he wielded a metal baseball bat at the officer.

Dublin police were responding to a domestic disturbance call shortly after 6 p.m. in the 7000 block of Dublin Meadows Street when they were met at the front door by Herrera, who was holding the bat, Dublin Police Lt. Herb Walters said.

One officer drew his pistol as the bat struck him on his right hand, which was holding the weapon, according to Walters. Police allege that Herrera then raised the baseball bat over his head, aiming at the officer's head.

Walters said the officer believed his life was in danger and fired four rounds at Herrera.

Medical personnel responded to the scene, but Herrera succumbed to his injuries.

Dublin police conducted interviews throughout Sunday night and learned that a family member had asked a friend to call the police because Herrera was being physical with his mother, Walters said. The friend reported to police that Herrera had pushed her and was possibly confrontational due to the effects of going through a drug detox program.

According to police, the witness interviews were consistent with the report that Herrera attacked the officer with a baseball bat.

Police also learned that last Saturday, Livermore police were called to an incident where Herrera allegedly was using methamphetamine, attacked a friend and threatened to eat him. When Livermore police arrived, Herrera was covered in blood and began fighting with the officers, according to Walters.

Police in Livermore had to use their Taser to gain control of Herrera, according to Walters. He was then transported to a local hospital for treatment. Herrera called his mother on Sunday morning to pick him up at the hospital because he decided to leave against the medical advice of the doctor treating him, according to police.

Herrera had a criminal history of assaults, possession of weapons and drugs, and resisting arrest, according to Walters.


Like this comment
Posted by William Tell
a resident of Another Pleasanton neighborhood
on May 5, 2014 at 9:16 am

I hope to God the guy was white, otherwise there will be public outcry regarding police use of deadly force against a criminal of color.

Like this comment
Posted by Julia
a resident of another community
on May 5, 2014 at 9:22 am

It is too bad our law officers can not deal with folks using a baseball bat etc etc.

I guess they are not trained well enough in self defense without pulling their hand gun and shooting the person not once in the leg but several rounds into the upper body to kill them...

These cops are not trained well at time Mr. Cop shoot the hell out of him in the legs he or she will drop and you can cuff them...I think I know why you kill them...

Just my opinion, Thanks for listening, Julia Pardini, from Alamo

Like this comment
Posted by Citizen
a resident of Another Pleasanton neighborhood
on May 5, 2014 at 10:53 am

Anyone going at a police officer with a weapon (stick, bat or knife) can expect to be shot!! Some people don't have a clue about how to defend oneself with a firearm! Julia!

Like this comment
Posted by Cholo
a resident of Livermore
on May 5, 2014 at 11:34 am

pretty is as pretty does...i rest my case

Like this comment
Posted by Cholo
a resident of Livermore
on May 5, 2014 at 11:45 am

Was a Taser available to take him down?

Like this comment
Posted by What's wrong with you Julia?
a resident of Downtown
on May 5, 2014 at 11:54 am

Julia, (removed) No officer should ever have to defend himself from ANY attack with ANY weapon. Why don't you suggest that the officer just speak quietly and give the attacker a time out to calm down?

For the record, the office was quite capable of dealing with the attacker who had the baseball bat. I commend that officer for getting rid of such a useless and harmful moron.

Like this comment
Posted by Don Sterling
a resident of another community
on May 5, 2014 at 12:02 pm

Yes, even if you shoot the guy 2 or 3 times in the legs, he can still quickly get up and use the baseball bat against the officers. Because, you know, two or more police officers are no match for a guy with three bullets in his legs with a baseball bat in his hand, especially if he's black.

Kudos to the PW for allowing posters' racial comments to stand. For, after all, it is only posters who claim the city or the newspaper is racist who deserve to be censored. How dare they say that about our good city and fine newspaper? In case you hadn't heard, we live in a society where racism no longer exists.

Like this comment
Posted by kbenson
a resident of Bordeaux Estates
on May 5, 2014 at 1:57 pm

Reading the story on SF gate it appears that 2 officers responded.

The person with the bat was 18 and living with his mom + sister. Supposedly the 18yr old was suffering a nervous breakdown and someone "18 yr old mother?" said "don't shoot" shortly before shots were fired.

I agree with Julia in this case. 2 officers on the scene the other officer could have used his baton or taser. Not sure why one would have to fire more than 2 rounds either.

Now a Mother is w/o her son who probably needed mental help.

Like this comment
Posted by Researcher
a resident of Foothill Farms
on May 5, 2014 at 3:54 pm

Well, if you're a cop and you're not sufficiently trained, you're scared to death of people of color, you have the gun, and you're virtually certain the reportage will be in your favor and superiors' reviews will also be in your favor, then it's understandable why you'd 'fire away'.

Three years ago when I was doing research on this, over a 5 year period not a single police officer was found guilty of murder in cases like these -- in all of America. To run from a cop who shouts "Stop" is a felony, and the cop is then within his "rights" to fire away.

Sick as it is, that's the way it is.

Like this comment
Posted by Cholo
a resident of Livermore
on May 5, 2014 at 3:54 pm

It's not cool when anybody gets killed.

I never appreciate using a gun unless it's absolutely necessary. Hopefully the case will be reviewed and alternative solutions seriously discussed.

Taser's are very effective in taking down hostile folks. I don't quite understand what exactly happened?

Quite sad.

Like this comment
Posted by Dave
a resident of San Ramon
on May 5, 2014 at 4:38 pm

I side on the p.d. If someone raises a bat over their head (especially to a police officer) his intent is to kill, and in my opinion he is insane. Firing upon the bat handler is what i would do and this notion about shooting the person in the legs, people, really, you are trying to stop an insane person who is trying to kill you, you can try to aim at a leg that is 2-3' long and about 3-4" wide or a torso that is 1'-4" X 2'-6", SHOOT AT THE BIGGER TARGET, YOU ARE MORE LIKELY TO HIT SOMETHING, as the officer did and he should be commended. I am wondering why the Livermore Police did not arrest this man after tasing him over the weekend???

Like this comment
Posted by Pleasant Onion
a resident of Bridle Creek
on May 5, 2014 at 5:04 pm

It is certainly my impression that cops are a great deal more trigger-happy than they once were. It seems like a military mentality, and we are the citizenry of some occupied land. So, it's "shoot first and then go on paid administrative leave later." Anybody have some actual stats?

Think about it -- what would you do if you were just a neighbor, trying to help out? You'd retreat to safety and work with your partner. Not these guys. KaPowie, center mass. Repeatedly.

It makes me very hesitant to call on them, for fear they'll make allmost any disturbance situation much worse.

Protect and Serve?

Like this comment
Posted by Jake
a resident of Another Pleasanton neighborhood
on May 5, 2014 at 7:16 pm


These so called police need to be investigated for murder. There is no excuse for this. I hope they go to jail for a long time. They are the criminals in this case.

No sympathy from me. LOCK THEM UP!!

Like this comment
Posted by nunya
a resident of Pleasanton Heights
on May 5, 2014 at 7:39 pm

Does anyone know how many times this civilian was shot in the back? I wonder if the name of the killer, I mean deputy, will be made public?

Like this comment
Posted by Julia is a
a resident of Mohr Park
on May 5, 2014 at 7:56 pm

Very insightful comments from people with zero training in self-defense, apprproiate use of force, and the stopping power of lethal and non-lethal weapons. Since you are all so smart please spend a few weekends riding along with PD to demonstrate the best ways to disarm viloent people. Be sure you have the opportunity to put yourself in harm's way and literally make a life a death decision in a split second. Where is your outrage over the scumbags who severely beat two deputies this weekend in Castro Valley?

Like this comment
Posted by Jake
a resident of Another Pleasanton neighborhood
on May 5, 2014 at 8:41 pm

"Very insightful comments ..."

What a bunch of BS. Why don't you go "ride along" with the PD. Go knock yourself out.

Sounds to me like the "police" need the training. They need to be made an example of. Send them to jail for a long time!

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Sound and Fury over Vile and Slur-ry
By Tom Cushing | 96 comments | 1,448 views

New state housing requirements could affect Pleasanton
By Jeb Bing | 6 comments | 583 views

Time for new collaboration between city and school district
By Tim Hunt | 1 comment | 368 views