Town Square

Post a New Topic

Will BART workers wake up to reality?

Original post made by Tim Hunt on Aug 1, 2013

Thanks to excellent reporting by the Bay Area News Group in its Sunday editions you can see just how richly compensated BART employees are as they continue locked in a labor dispute and could issue a 72-hour alert of a strike today.
Past management and the elected officials responsible for the taxpayers' interests have kowtowed to the unions for way too long. BART employees represented in the labor dispute hold positions that require little more than a high school degree yet they are the highest compensated transportation workers in the state and their compensation soars above other public agencies in the state.
BART employees pull down more than $20,000 more than their peers in the Los Angeles, Orange County and Sacramento transportation agencies and more than $15,000 more than AC Transit.
Even more interesting is how much the agency tops other large public organizations. BART gross compensation averages $83,000 while schools districts are less than half of that at $32-35k.

Toss in that school district employees always have paid their 8 percent share of their pension costs—BART employees contribute nothing and pay only $92 a month for family health insurance. Can you say "sweet?"
In reporting this week, BART officials said they have now offered 8 percent over four years regardless of economic conditions. In exchange, they want employees to pay 5 percent of their pension costs (currently they pay nothing) and gradually move from paying a flat $92 for health care to 10 percent of the actual costs. The flat rate amounts to about 5 percent that would about double over four years to $184 or more, given the rate of increase in health care costs. Health care benefits and pensions costs are driving public agencies toward bankruptcy.
In addition, BART needs to replace most of its rolling stock and has precious little money. In contrast to private enterprise that would save money for capital improvements, BART needs to do all it can to pay cash out of pocket because there's no routine reserve for capital equipment replacement reserve. The options typically are begging for federal money or further raising fares. Given the tone in Congress and the train wreck of a federal budget spending (borrowing 40 cents on every dollar), there's little chance of seeing that happen.
BART management and the board should consider the approach President Ronald Reagan took when the air traffic controllers walked off the job. If the workers decide to go out, hire permanent replacements. If the air traffic control system—life and death—can survive that step, surely an agency with automated trains can do the same if the recalcitrant union will not wake up to reality.
There are plenty of examples of public employee unions being reasonable. Look no farther than the Pleasanton city employees who have resumed paying their appropriate share of their pension contributions.

Comments (2)

Posted by Daveg, a resident of Birdland
on Aug 1, 2013 at 2:16 pm

Daveg is a registered user.

Tim, I think you have done a good job in identifying why the BART union is being unreasonable in their demands. Regarding following the approach that Regan used, I think that management gave that possibility away sometime ago. For starters, BART has only 10 qualified operators who are not in the Amalgamated Transit Union.
If management wanted to add more, it would have to put them through special training mandated under the union contract signed after the 1979 labor dispute.
It's not that becoming a BART driver requires a lot of experience. The trains are automated, so operators drive them only during emergencies, and then only to speeds up to 25 mph.
To qualify for training, a candidate needs a high school diploma or GED, a valid California driver's license and three years of experience "interacting with the general public in a variety of ways," according to the posted job description.
Operators also must pass a 15-week training course in safety practices. Under the agency's contract, however, anyone is barred from even taking the course as long as union BART operators are on the job.
In other words, the only time BART can begin training replacement operators is when drivers go out on strike.
So if there is a strike, it will take months to get replacement operators in the trains —unless BART files paperwork with the California Public Utilities Commission to change the training requirements. And who knows how long that would take?"


Posted by Daveg, a resident of Birdland
on Aug 12, 2013 at 4:11 pm

Daveg is a registered user.

Tim, perhaps it's time to update us on the current "demands" from the BART union. There are still a few that appear to not be fully aware of the current benefits enjoyed by the union brethren and unsure of what the demands are currently from the unions. Hopefully, BART management will continue in their efforts to rein in costs that cannot be sustained without real damage to both the BART infrastructure and the general public that needs to use BART.


If you were a member and logged in you could track comments from this story.

To post your comment, please click here to login

Remember me?
Forgot Password?
or register. This topic is only for those who have signed up to participate by providing their email address and establishing a screen name.

Moneyball, the Sequel: Billy Beane for President!
By Tom Cushing | 6 comments | 1,045 views

Planning the "Pleasanton way"
By Tim Hunt | 13 comments | 926 views

Getting rid of an old toilet
By Roz Rogoff | 8 comments | 494 views

Take Full Advantage of Free Standardized Testing Opportunities
By Elizabeth LaScala | 0 comments | 457 views